How to program WP to Sorting Contact Form Responses into 2 List

Hello Everybody,

Newby here.  I have a WP site and I'm trying to get my responses (ex. Form 1= General Interest: Add to email listing.  Form 2=Volunteer) and I'd like to have them sorted when they come into my list here at Constant Contact.  

Can someone tell me what to do from here because this is not working. 

TIA