Sign-up Form Not Rendering on New Account with New Form

I recently create a new account and am having trouble with the sign-up form displaying on my WordPress (.org) website. When I'm logged into WordPress, the sign-up form renders fine and it functions fine. When I am logged out or use a private window, the form is not even visible on the page. Url is greenmountainbywayvt.com and the sign up form is inline and should appear in the footer.