Sudden drop in email open rates

Our church email list experiences a very high open rate for our email campaigns - averaging around 60 percent for the past two years or so.

As of Feb. 4, our open rate has dropped to a half of that or less. There has been no change in our email content - these are routine emails that go out every week or every other week. So I know that this is not an 'email fatigue' issue.

I have analyzed the specific email open lists before and after Feb 4 to determine if any specific client email mail server was the culprit. About half of those who previously opened emails are using Gmail addresses. The rest are a mix of Comcast, Verizon, AOL, Yahoo and others, which does not speak to any easy client mail server issues.

What else could be causing this? Did Constant Contact make any recent changes in how they count open emails?

2
28 replies
Best reply by Kyle B

Hi all,

We've rolled these changes back as of last night. The team is going to be working on a number of enhancements before we consider turning this back on, including:

  • Proxy open drilldown report

  • Classic Open Rate available on the Email Details page

  • Updated Sankey chart that does not categories proxy opens as "non-openers"

Once those changes are live, we'll slowly go through the rollout process again. Your open rates may not update immediately -- they're on a recalc schedule that I've posted below:

--Kyle

View original
Webinar

Is your small business or nonprofit losing time and engagement to outdated or confusing social media advice? April 23, 2026 2:00 pm ET

Popular Posts:

The world's largest virtual email marketing conference. November 12-13th.